U.S. Sen. John Cornyn (R-Texas) is blocking President Donald Trump’s pick for a lifetime federal judgeship in Dallas during the Senate’s lame duck session. Heritage Foundation President Kevin Roberts says Cornyn is giving his Democratic successor, James Talarico, a head start.
U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) says T. Elliot Gaiser is the only candidate Republicans can confirm before Democrats take control of the Senate in January. Cornyn wants the White House to choose Fort Worth lawyer and former federal prosecutor Steve Fahey instead.
‘What a legacy’
“John Cornyn is going out as the Republican Texas Senator who helped get radical leftist James Talarico’s agenda started early. What a legacy,” Roberts wrote Thursday on X. Talarico defeated Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton on November 3 to win Cornyn’s seat.
John Cornyn is going out as the Republican Texas Senator who helped get radical leftist James Talarico’s agenda started early. What a legacy. pic.twitter.com/aoniaaBN9M
— Kevin Roberts (@KevinRobertsTX) November 19, 2026
“Kevin, your sycophancy has destroyed the credibility of a once great institution, and in so doing you have made yourself irrelevant,” Cornyn replied.
Roberts answered that Heritage and three other groups would still be “fighting for the everyday American, not K Street” after Cornyn left office. He called Gaiser “one of the most brilliant legal minds of this generation” and told Cornyn that “your pettiness will give this seat to a Radical Leftist judge.”
“Who’s destroyed whose credibility?” Roberts asked.
Whose blue slip counts in January?
Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) urged Republicans on November 10 to use their remaining weeks in the majority to confirm as many of Trump’s judges as possible. When Trump sent Gaiser’s nomination to the Senate on Monday, Cornyn withheld his blue slip, the form the committee seeks from both home-state senators for a district court nominee. Gaiser missed Wednesday’s hearing.
Cornyn said Gaiser had bypassed the bipartisan Texas panel that interviews judicial candidates. Gaiser, a former Ohio solicitor general, already had Senate approval for a different job. Cornyn and Cruz both voted to confirm him as an assistant attorney general in July 2025.
Cruz said the White House told him a replacement could not clear a fresh FBI background check in time. He warned that Democrats could keep the Dallas seat vacant.
The Senate still listed Gaiser’s nomination in committee Friday. If the seat stays open into the new Congress, Talarico will take Cornyn’s place as one of the two Texas senators consulted on the nomination. Democrats will control the confirmation vote.