Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton won a significant legal victory at the state’s highest court, clearing the path for his lawsuit against a border aid organization to proceed.
The Supreme Court of Texas overturned a lower court injunction that had halted Paxton’s prosecution of Annunciation House, an El Paso nonprofit accused of illegally harboring undocumented immigrants.
“Today is a great victory for Texas, secure borders, and the rule of law,” Paxton said in a press release following the ruling. “Annunciation House has flagrantly violated our laws by harboring illegal aliens and assisting them to enter further into our country.”
The case stems from a 2024 lawsuit filed by Paxton’s office against the El Paso-based organization. The Attorney General alleges the group operates as a “stash house” in violation of Texas Penal Code provisions.
Paxton’s legal team built its case on what it describes as substantial public evidence and employee admissions. They argue that these revelations demonstrate systematic law violations by the nonprofit organization.
An El Paso County district judge initially granted Annunciation House’s request for an injunction, effectively halting the state’s legal action against the Catholic-affiliated aid group.
The state Supreme Court’s decision addressed more than just procedural matters. Justices explicitly rejected claims that Paxton targeted the organization because of its religious connections.
The high court found “no evidence to support” accusations of religious discrimination in the case. Justices also reminded the trial court to presume the Attorney General acted in “good faith” and with “legality.”
Paxton vowed to continue his enforcement efforts against similar organizations.
“I will do everything in my power to stop them and any other NGO breaking our laws,” he stated.
Amy Warr, an attorney for Annunciation House, argued before the Texas Supreme Court that the religious organization has not broken any laws and has never hidden immigrants from law enforcement officers. She claimed that Paxton’s attack against the nongovernmental organization is just anti-immigration political rhetoric, the El Paso Times reported.
The ruling represents another chapter in ongoing tensions over immigration enforcement along the Texas-Mexico border. Humanitarian aid organizations are frequently caught between federal immigration policy and state-level prosecution efforts.
With the injunction lifted, the case returns to the trial court level. Annunciation House will face the underlying criminal allegations in proceedings that can now proceed.