Texas prison officials struggled to insert intravenous lines before executing convicted murderer Reinaldo Dennes on November 19, while witnesses heard the prisoner cry out about pain after the injection began. The 63-minute procedure has renewed questions about the reliability of lethal injection and whether other execution methods could reduce suffering.
Dennes, 70, died at 7:08 p.m. at the Huntsville Unit, one minute after officials completed the procedure. Staff ultimately placed IV lines in his left foot and the left side of his neck following several unsuccessful attempts, Texas Department of Criminal Justice spokesperson Amanda Hernandez told the Associated Press.
“The pain!” Dennes exclaimed shortly after the procedure began, according to AP correspondent Michael Graczyk, who witnessed the execution and has attended nearly 500 others in Texas. He described Dennes moaning repeatedly for almost three minutes and complaining that his right leg hurt. The witness could not determine the medical cause of the distress.
Hernandez said the execution team followed state procedures. She questioned the complaints because Dennes also described pain before drugs began to flow and in locations without IV lines. The agency has not publicly established whether the drugs or IV placement caused his reactions, according to the account.
A Murder Conviction And A Family’s Long Wait
Dennes received a death sentence for the January 24, 1996, robbery and murder of Houston diamond dealer Janos Szucs. The attack also injured security guard David Copeland. Texas prison records identify Dennes and his co-defendants in the case.
Copeland died before the execution.
The U.S. Supreme Court denied Dennes’ application for a stay November 19; that ruling preceded the execution and did not evaluate how officials carried it out.
A Woman Who Survived The Drugs
The Texas episode follows Tennessee’s failed September 30 attempt to execute Christa Gail Pike for the 1995 murder of Colleen Slemmer, 19. Officials gave Pike two doses of pentobarbital, but she survived. Her attorneys say the IVs malfunctioned and drugs may have leaked into her tissues rather than circulating properly. Those allegations have not received a final judicial determination.
The Dallas Express previously examined her case and later covered her recovery. Tennessee Gov. Bill Lee suspended the state’s remaining 2026 executions and called for an independent review.
The legal dispute continues.
Pike’s attorneys filed an emergency motion challenging her confinement in a prison infirmary after she returned from the hospital. A federal court scheduled a December 1 hearing on that separate confinement issue, according to a November 16 update by People. No new execution date had emerged from the reviewed records as of November 20.
A second attempt would not automatically violate the Constitution.
In the 1947 case Louisiana ex rel. Francis v. Resweber, the Supreme Court allowed Louisiana to try again after an electric chair malfunction, although Pike’s circumstances and medical injuries could produce distinct legal arguments.
Are Firing Squads More Reliable?
A historical study by Amherst College professor Austin Sarat examined 8,776 U.S. executions from 1890 through 2010 and classified 276, or 3.15%, as botched.
The analysis counted 75 of 1,054 lethal injections (7.2%) and 85 of 2,721 hangings (3.12%) as botched. It identified no botched firing squad executions among 34 cases, although historical accounts dispute that zero-failure characterization.
Those figures track reported procedural problems, not pain, and do not describe the performance of modern execution teams.
A firing squad can miss its intended target: an autopsy after South Carolina’s April 2025 execution of Mikal Mahdi found that only two of three bullets struck him and neither hit his heart, according to the Death Penalty Information Center’s review. Hanging can cause prolonged strangulation when a fall fails to break the neck.
Neither history nor existing medical evidence establishes that any execution method guarantees immediate unconsciousness or a painless death.
Why Texas Still Uses Lethal Injection
Texas adopted lethal injection in 1977 and became the first state to carry out an execution by that method on December 7, 1982, when it executed Charles Brooks Jr. of Tarrant County, according to the state prison system’s history. The change reflected the search for a method that officials regarded as less visibly violent than older approaches.
Today, Article 43.14 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure requires intravenous injection of lethal substances. Prison administrators cannot independently replace it with hanging or a firing squad. Legislators would have to change the state law, subject to constitutional limits.
When Does Pain Become Cruel And Unusual Punishment?
The Eighth Amendment prohibits cruel and unusual punishments, but courts distinguish an inherently unconstitutional execution method from the possibility that a lawful procedure might cause pain.
In Bucklew v. Precythe (2019), the Supreme Court held that method-of-execution challenges generally require evidence of a substantial risk of severe pain and a feasible, readily implemented alternative that significantly reduces that risk. An alternative need not already appear in state law.
Consequently, an execution that takes 63 minutes is not automatically unconstitutional.
The facts of Dennes’ case could inform scrutiny of IV procedures, staff training, recordkeeping and the medical explanation for his complaints, but no court has ruled that the November 19 procedure violated the Eighth Amendment.
The distinction leaves a concrete public-policy question for Texas lawmakers: whether the state’s legally mandated method works as reliably as intended, and what evidence the government should provide when witnesses describe an execution going wrong.