DX
Download Download Now
Health & Science

Afraid Of Your Own Mind: Can Sleeplessness And Sleep Aids Worsen Intrusive Thoughts?

Can Sleep Aids And Insomnia Worsen Intrusive Thoughts? | Image by Tero Vesalainen/Shutterstock

A kitchen knife sits on the counter. Its owner catches sight of it and, for a split second, imagines hurting someone she loves. She puts it away, unsettled by a thought she neither wanted nor chose.

Years later, she is lying awake beside her beloved cat when another disturbing image crosses her mind. She has no desire to harm the animal, yet she cannot shake the fear that the thought might mean something about her.

The scenario is hypothetical, but the experience it illustrates is familiar to clinicians who treat unwanted, harm-related thoughts. For some people, the distress comes not from wanting to hurt anyone but from wondering whether they can trust themselves.

Now add chronic insomnia, a prescription sleeping pill, or a cannabis gummy. Could an exhausted or drug-affected mind make those thoughts harder to dismiss?

Molly Martinez, PhD, a Texas-licensed clinical psychologist and founder of Richardson-based Specialists in OCD & Anxiety Recovery (SOAR), told The Dallas Express in an exclusive written interview that sleep deprivation can make unwanted thoughts more difficult to manage.

Martinez, who earned her doctorate from The Ohio State University, founded SOAR in 2018 and joined the faculty of the International OCD Foundation’s Behavioral Therapy Training Institute in 2023. She trains other mental health professionals in evidence-based treatment for obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) and related conditions.

“Yes, research has found that sleep deprivation makes it harder for the brain to manage unwanted memories, thoughts, and feelings,” Martinez stated. “Nighttime anxiety can make intrusive, unwanted thoughts feel more frightening and more significant than they would otherwise be.”

“A study by the Universities of York and Cambridge (Harrington et al 2021) found that people who had been deprived of sleep experienced up to 50% more unwanted thoughts than those who’d had a normal night’s sleep.” 


A Nation Searching For Sleep

In April 2026, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) reported that 30.5% of American adults averaged fewer than seven hours of sleep in a 24-hour period in 2024. About 15.4% had difficulty falling asleep most days or every day, and 18.1% frequently struggled to stay asleep.

A separate CDC report, also published in April, found that 12.9% of adults used sleep aids most days or every day during the preceding month. Prescription medications accounted for 5.2% of adults, over-the-counter medicines or supplements for 5.7%, and marijuana or CBD products for 3.7%. Respondents could use more than one type.

Women reported more frequent sleep-aid use than men, 14.8% versus 10.8%. Among adults 65 and older, 15.8% regularly used sleep aids.


When A Thought Becomes A Fear

The National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH) identifies unwanted aggressive thoughts and fears of losing behavioral control among possible symptoms of obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). An intrusive thought can be an image, idea, or apparent impulse that enters awareness without invitation.

“People with recurring intrusive thoughts may have OCD. Some people don’t think they have OCD because they can’t identify any compulsions. They don’t realize compulsions can be performed mentally in many ways. There are a lot of misconceptions about OCD. OCD is not just about being organized, clean, and perfect; it can take many different forms,” Martinez stated to The Dallas Express.

Not everyone who experiences one has OCD. But persistent, distressing thoughts that lead to repetitive rituals, avoidance, or significant disruption may warrant assessment for the disorder.

The International OCD Foundation describes how violent obsessions can involve fear of harming family members or other people, and how sufferers may avoid knives and other objects they associate with the feared act.

Such thoughts may be ego-dystonic — inconsistent with a person’s values and desires. A loving pet owner may be disturbed precisely because the image contradicts how they feel about the animal.

The fear can become self-reinforcing. Putting away a knife provides temporary relief. But someone who begins treating every knife as a threat may find that the sight of one provokes increasing anxiety. Repeatedly seeking reassurance, reviewing past behavior, or trying to prove that a thought could never come true can become part of the cycle.

“Thoughts are not the same as intentions,” Martinez stated to The Dallas Express. “Having a thought does not mean you want to act on it or will act on it accidentally, impulsively, or out of control.”

The distinction is crucial: An unwanted image is not the same as a desire, plan, or intention.

A clinician must still evaluate genuine safety concerns and determine whether other conditions or medications could be involved.


What Sleep Loss Does To The Mind

A study published in the January 2025 issue of Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences offers a neurological clue. Researchers found that sleep-deprived healthy adults had more difficulty preventing unwanted memories from entering awareness. Brain imaging showed reduced engagement of systems involved in inhibiting memory retrieval.

The study did not measure violent obsessions or predict violent behavior. It did, however, provide experimental evidence that a night without sleep can impair a form of mental control.

Anxiety can make the experience particularly difficult at bedtime. A disturbing thought raises alertness, the person begins monitoring their mind, and sleep becomes harder to achieve. The next evening, fear of another sleepless night may add to the pressure.


Ambien CR And Unusual Mental Experiences

Zolpidem, sold as Ambien and Ambien CR, is prescribed for insomnia. The extended-release formulation is intended to help patients fall asleep and stay asleep.

The drug’s official prescribing information documents reports of abnormal thinking and behavioral changes, including agitation, reduced inhibition, out-of-character aggression, feelings of detachment, and hallucinations. Delirium has also been reported after marketing.

The label cautions that determining whether such changes stem from the medication or an underlying condition is often difficult, but concerning new behavioral symptoms require evaluation.

“Intrusive thoughts could certainly feel much worse if a substance causes confusion, anxiety, or alters perception,” according to Martinez.

A person who has experienced occasional knife-related intrusive thoughts since adolescence and notices more frequent or vivid thoughts after starting zolpidem has reason to discuss that change with a prescriber. It does not establish that the medication caused the symptoms, nor does it establish that the person has developed a new psychiatric disorder.

Timing is useful: Do the experiences occur before the dose, after it, or while drifting into sleep? Is the person fully aware and able to remember what happened, or are there episodes of confusion or missing memories?

Dose is another consideration. The recommended starting dose of Ambien CR for women is 6.25 milligrams; men may start at 6.25 or 12.5 milligrams. Women generally clear zolpidem more slowly, and the higher dose can increase next-day impairment.

The drug also carries a boxed warning about complex sleep behaviors, including activities performed while not fully awake, sometimes without subsequent memory. Serious injuries and deaths have occurred. This is distinct from an unwanted thought experienced while fully awake.

Patients who experience complex sleep behaviors should stop zolpidem and contact their healthcare professional immediately. Those experiencing other new or worsening mental symptoms should seek prompt medical guidance before the next dose; regularly used zolpidem can cause withdrawal or rebound insomnia if stopped abruptly, so a clinician should guide any taper or change.


THC Gummies: Relaxation Is Not Guaranteed

Cannabis products have become another part of the American sleep-aid landscape. In Texas, their risks have been the subject of public concern and regulatory debate.

The Dallas Express previously reported that at least seven attendees at a Prosper graduation celebration in 2025 were taken to hospitals after consuming THC gummies. That incident involved acute adverse reactions, not intrusive thoughts, but it illustrates why edible products should not be assumed harmless.

The CDC notes that cannabis can produce disorientation, anxiety, paranoia, and unpleasant thoughts. THC, its primary intoxicating compound, can affect people differently depending on exposure and individual susceptibility.

For someone already frightened by unwanted thoughts, the altered sensations or anxiety associated with THC could amplify distress.


Sugar And Caffeine: What The Evidence Actually Shows

A February 2026 systematic review in Stress and Health examined 27 articles on caffeine and anxiety. The authors found evidence that higher caffeine exposure can increase anxiety, with differences according to habitual consumption.

Caffeine-related insomnia may also contribute to anxiety.

Diet may also affect sleep. A 2016 study in the Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine linked higher sugar intake to more nighttime arousals. A 2020 analysis of postmenopausal women linked higher dietary glycemic index and added sugar intake with insomnia risk.

Diet and caffeine may influence sleep, and poor sleep can make emotional or cognitive regulation more difficult.


Melatonin And Nightmares

Melatonin helps regulate the body’s sleep-wake timing. Supplements may cause vivid dreams or nightmares in some people, according to Mayo Clinic.

A nightmare during sleep is different from a disturbing mental image while fully awake.

Dreamlike experiences may also occur during the transition into sleep, which is another reason clinicians may ask about the person’s level of awareness.

“People who experience intrusive thoughts sometimes describe these thoughts as being their “worst nightmare,” but they aren’t literally nightmares. Nightmares occur during sleep. Nightmares may feel very real while we experience them, but we typically understand that it was just a bad dream once we are fully awake. Sometimes people are so shaken by a nightmare that their mind keeps returning to it, fearing what it may mean or dreading its return. Images and feelings remembered from a nightmare can become intrusive thoughts in this way,” explained Martinez to The Dallas Express.

“Sleep-related hallucinations are relatively common and can occur when a person is falling asleep or waking up. These are known as hypnagogic (occurring while falling asleep) and hypnopompic (occurring while waking up) hallucinations. Because they occur in that foggy period between wakefulness and sleep, these visual, auditory, or tactile hallucinations can be harder to distinguish from reality.”

Melatonin is not an established treatment for chronic insomnia. In July 2026, an Ohio State University health resource noted that its evidence is stronger for certain sleep-timing disorders and that supplement content can vary.

DX has previously covered calls for improved melatonin packaging and labeling following pediatric ingestion incidents.


What Can People Safely Take To Sleep?

There is no universal sleeping pill proven to prevent unwanted harm-related thoughts. The safest approach depends on the cause of insomnia, the patient’s medical history, other medications, and the nature of the mental symptoms.

“Strong evidence supports using Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Insomnia (CBT-I) to help improve sleep. This treatment aims to maintain healthy and consistent sleep hygiene and to identify and correct any environmental or behavioral associations that disrupt the natural sleep cycle. Insomnia can also be a symptom of depression, bipolar disorder, anxiety, or another psychiatric or medical disorder. Make sure to get a thorough assessment for the sleep disturbance, potentially including a sleep study,” Martinez shared with The Dallas Express.

The 2025 clinical practice guideline from the Department of Veterans Affairs and Department of Defense recommends cognitive behavioral therapy for insomnia (CBT-I) as the preferred treatment for chronic insomnia.

CBT-I addresses habits, schedules, and beliefs that maintain sleeplessness. It can help patients break the association between bed and prolonged wakefulness without introducing another sedating substance.

For people with OCD, NIMH identifies exposure and response prevention (ERP), a specialized form of cognitive behavioral therapy, as an effective treatment. A clinician trained in ERP can help patients reduce compulsive checking and avoidance through carefully planned exercises. Some patients may also benefit from medication for OCD itself.

“If you are experiencing repeated intrusive thoughts, I encourage you to reach out to the International OCD Foundation’s website (iocdf.org) to learn more about OCD and access trusted resources to learn more and connect to assessment and treatment providers. Exposure and Response Prevention (ERP) is the strongest research-supported treatment for intrusive thoughts associated with OCD,” explained Martinez.

When medication is appropriate, clinicians may consider low-dose doxepin or orexin receptor antagonists such as daridorexant, lemborexant, and suvorexant. These medications have different mechanisms from zolpidem, but they carry their own adverse effects and have not been shown to be safer specifically for people with harm-related intrusive thoughts. The guideline discourages routine use of melatonin, cannabis, and several other commonly used sleep aids for chronic insomnia.

An evaluation may also identify other contributors, including sleep apnea, pain, anxiety, or a medication that interferes with sleep. Treating those conditions may be more helpful than switching from one sedative to another.


When To Ask For Help

Someone experiencing a longstanding pattern of unwanted thoughts need not wait until the symptoms become unbearable before seeking help. A useful starting point is to tell a clinician when the thoughts began, whether they have changed, whether they are unwanted, and whether they follow a medication dose or substance use.

“It’s important to tell someone what you are experiencing so you can get the help you need,” Martinez stated to The Dallas Express.

“In my practice as an OCD specialist, I meet many people who suffer in silence and shame because they are so afraid to tell others about the intrusive thoughts they are having. The thoughts themselves can be very scary; adding to that is the fear of judgment and repercussions from telling others. People are often afraid of being hospitalized or put in jail because they fear being misunderstood. Finding a provider who specializes in treating OCD is a good first step. Remember that thoughts are not facts; they will come and go like the weather.”

For recurring intrusive thoughts, clinicians may recommend learning to notice an unwanted mental event without repeatedly analyzing what it means. Practical sleep measures include a consistent wake-up time, reducing late-day caffeine, and avoiding alcohol or additional sedatives with sleep medication. A brief record of sleep and medication timing may help identify patterns without turning into another form of compulsive monitoring.

New or worsening symptoms after a sleep medication warrant prompt contact with the prescriber, preferably before the next dose. A person should not deliberately repeat a suspected trigger to test its effects or independently combine sleep aids.

Actual intent to harm, an inability to control one’s actions, severe confusion, hallucinations, or unexplained behavior and memory gaps warrant urgent assessment. If someone is at imminent risk of harming another person or animal, they should move away from potential weapons and the person or animal, enlist trusted support, and call 911. The 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline also offers crisis support by phone or text.

For someone who has spent years putting away kitchen knives or quietly questioning why a disturbing thought appeared, the prospect of discussing it may feel daunting. But an unwanted thought alone does not establish violent intent, and effective treatment exists for the conditions that can make such thoughts persistent.

“Intrusive thoughts are like farts–they can pop up unexpectedly, be really gross, uncomfortable, and awkward, and they go away all on their own without us having to do anything about them. They only have the significance we give them, and trying to force them away actually keeps us in contact with them,” explained Martinez to The Dallas Express.

“Like a game of tug-of-war, pulling away keeps you connected to the thought. The key to getting rid of intrusive thoughts is learning how to drop the rope. Intrusive thoughts do not need to be feared or analyzed in depth. They are not facts.”

For those struggling with both insomnia and disturbing intrusive thoughts, understanding the difference between an unwanted thought and an intention to act may be the first step toward finding relief, restoring confidence, and reclaiming a restful night’s sleep.


This article is for informational purposes only and is not intended to substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Readers should consult a qualified healthcare professional regarding any medical or mental health concerns and before starting, stopping, or changing any medication or supplement.

Previous Article
Blood Marker Shows Promise For Detecting Advanced CTE During Life Blood Marker Shows Promise For Detecting Advanced CTE During Life